The Tasting Archives - Rankings of all beers evaluated by the Woodmoor Beer Appreciation Society

The table below lists from best to worst the beers evaluated by WBAS members during Society tastings. The list is current through the Belgia Ale tasting on 9 November 2009. The first ad hoc brown ale tasting conducted in 2000 was not included as the beers were not evaluated on the 50 point scale. You will notice that the last two columns show the range of scores each beer received during the evaluation. I have been reviewing scoring profiles for each member and it is clear that we have members that tend to be high and low scorers. Look for some statistical evaluation in the future and individual rating profiles.

 

BEER
Date Evaluated
Number of Ratings
AVG Score
High Low
 
Bear Republic Hop Rod Rye (8.0% abv)
13-Feb-07
8
42.8
47 19
Bigfoot 2001 Sierra Nevada
21-Jul-07
6
42.33
47 37
Winter Solstice Ale
8-Feb-08
12
41.88
50 22
Lagunitas IPA
21-Jan-01
5
40.8
48 33
Flying Dog Doggie Style Pale Ale
23-Feb-01
6
40.33
41 38
Corsendonk Abbey Pale Ale
9-Nov-08
10
39.6
46 35
Celebration Ale
8-Feb-08
10
39.1
45 28
Winter Storm
8-Feb-08
11
38.82
44 30
Stoudt's Winter Ale
8-Feb-08
12
38.67
45 30
Belgique Lunatique Abby Style Triple
9-Nov-08
10
38.6
45 31
Butterfield Mt. Whitney Pale Ale
3-Mar-00
5
38.4
43 35
Stone Brewing Arrogant Bastard (7.2% abv)
13-Feb-07
8
38.1
49 24
Old Dominion Dominion Pale Ale
20-Jan-07
9
37.89
44 31
Steelhead Extra Pale Ale
12-Feb-00
5
37.8
43 33
Brooklyn Lager
22-Dec-00
7
37.43
44 28
Lost Coast Indica IPA
21-Jan-01
5
37.4
40 35
Catamount Pale Ale
12-Feb-00
5
37.4
39 34
Bigfoot 2004 Sierra Nevada
21-Jul-07
7
37
46 23
Clipper City IPA
21-Jan-01
5
37
41 35
Schmaltz HeBrew Jewbelation (10% abv)
13-Feb-07
8
36.8
43 30
Wolaver's IPA
21-Jan-01
5
36.8
41 27
Mad Elf Ale
8-Feb-08
11
36.45
48 27
Black Chococlate Stout 2002 Brooklyn Brewery
21-Jul-07
6
36.33
42 26
Lindemann's Framboise
6-Jul-07
11
36.27
44 30
Black Chococlate Stout 2006 Brooklyn Brewery
21-Jul-07
6
36.16
46 27
Portland Woodstock IPA
21-Jan-01
5
36
44 28
Saranac Pale Ale
12-Feb-00
5
36
41 33
120 Minute IPA Dogfish Head
21-Jul-07
10
36
47 25
Golden Gate Original Ale
3-Mar-00
5
35.8
42 30
Duvel
9-Nov-09
10
35.6
43 29
Old Scratch (Flying Dog)
22-Dec-00
7
35.6
40 28
Avery's Ellie's Brown Ale
20-Jan-07
9
35.11
39 28
Orkney Skull Splitter (8.5% abv)
13-Feb-07
8
35
40 18
Smutty-nose Winter Ale
8-Feb-08
12
35
45 27
Tommy-knocker Maple
9-Nov-07
10
35
42 29
Anderson Valley Summer Solstice
12-Jul-08
14
34.93
41 26
Bigfoot 2007 Sierra Nevada
21-Jul-07
12
34.91
46 27
Aventinus
2-Jun-07
9
34.89
40 26
Pyramid Pale Ale
23-Feb-01
6
34.83
39 29
Curieux Allagash Brewery
21-Jul-07
6
34.83
43 26
Black Chococlate Stout 2003 Brooklyn Brewery
21-Jul-07
6
34.66
41 28
Dogfish Head Midas Touch
6-Jul-07
11
34.64
45 28
Christian Moerlein Select Lager
22-Dec-00
7
34.6
45 29
Foothill IBA (Imperial Brown Ale)
9-Nov-07
11
34.6
42 28
Winter-braun
8-Feb-08
12
34.25
42 19
Dogfish Head ApriHop
6-Jul-07
11
34.09
43 22
Brookyln Lager
7-Apr-07
9
33.89
39 31
Harviestoun Old Engine Oil (6.0% abv)
13-Feb-07
8
33.8
40 27
Bells Oberon Ale
12-Jul-08
14
33.79
41 26
Troegs Rugged Trail Brown Ale
9-Nov-07
11
33.75
43 28
Dogfish Head Indian Brown Ale
20-Jan-07
9
33.67
41 29
Blue Heron Pale Ale
12-Feb-00
5
33.6
36 30
Worldwide Stout Dogfish Head
21-Jul-07
7
33.28
41 23
Stoudt's American Pale Ale
20-Jan-07
9
33.22
46 15
Bells Brewing Third Coast Ale (10.2% abv)
13-Feb-07
8
33.1
43 27
Wells Banana Bread Beer
6-Jul-07
11
33.09
40 23
Blue Moon Honey Moon
12-Jul-08
14
33
40 26
Ayinger Ur Weizen
2-Jun-07
9
32.89
41 24
Rogue: Santa's Private Reserve
8-Feb-08
11
32.73
43 23
Samuel Adams Winter Welcome (6.0% abv)
13-Feb-07
8
32.5
46 19
JW Lees Harvest Ale (11.5% abv)
13-Feb-07
8
32.5
40 14
Tupper's Hop Pocket Ale
23-Feb-01
6
32.5
40 25
Snow-cap
8-Feb-08
12
32.5
44 21
Rogue Juniper Ale
6-Jul-07
11
32.36
42 25
Smuttynose Portsmouth Lager
7-Apr-07
9
32.33
40 25
Portland Pale Ale
3-Mar-00
5
31.6
34 27
Sierra Nevada Pale Ale
23-Feb-01
6
31.5
39 24
Cuvee Euphorique
9-Nov-09
11
31.36
43 24
Fraoch Heather Ale
6-Jul-07
11
31.36
38 22
Monster 2003 Brooklyn Brewery
21-Jul-07
8
31.25
37 27
Foggy Bottom Lager
22-Dec-00
7
31.14
40 25
Smuttynose Shoals Pale Ale
20-Jan-07
9
31.11
44 22
Newcastle Brown Ale
Jan Nov 07
20
31.1
45 21
Left Hand Sawtooth Pale Ale
3-Mar-00
5
31
40 15
Backdraft Brown
9-Nov-07
11
31
42 24
Kelpie Seaweed Ale
6-Jul-07
11
30.82
37 20
Green Flash Nut Brown Ale
Jan Nov 07
19
30.78
45 22
Brasserie Des Rocs Grand Cru
9-Nov-08
10
30.7
37 26
Ommegang Witte
2-Jun-07
9
30.67
43 18
Sam Adams TripleBock
21-Jul-07
3
30.66
41 22
Otter Creek Summer Ale
12-Jul-08
14
30.64
41 16
Wild Goose Nut Brown Ale
9-Nov-07
10
30.4
36 25
Old Dominion Lager
22-Dec-00
7
30.4
38 14
Lagunitas Dogtown Pale Ale
23-Feb-01
6
30.17
34 26
Monster 2000 Brooklyn Brewery
21-Jul-07
9
30.11
40 19
Samuel Smith Nut Brown Ale
Jan Nov 07
20
29.95
45 14
Magic Hat Fat Angel
20-Jan-07
9
29.89
39 23
Weihenstephaner Kristall Weisse
2-Jun-07
9
29.89
40 16
Geary's Pale Ale
3-Mar-00
5
29.8
32 25
Isle of Skye Wee Beast (7.0% abv)
13-Feb-07
8
29.6
41 21
Mendocino Blue Herron Pale Ale
20-Jan-07
9
29.22
36 24
Sam Adams Boston Ale
12-Feb-00
5
29
34 19
Thomas Hardy's Ale 1996
21-Jul-07
9
29
45 19
Millenium Ale 1999 Dominion Brewery
21-Jul-07
7
28.75
39 18
Brooklyn Pennant Pale Ale
3-Mar-00
5
27.8
34 24
Sam Adams Summer Ale
12-Jul-08
14
27.77
36 19
Harpoon Summer Beer (Kolsh)
12-Jul-08
16
27.75
35 21
Aecht Smoked Marzen
6-Jul-07
11
27.73
41 7
Paulaner Original Munich
7-Apr-07
9
27.67
43 15
Harpoon IPA
21-Jan-01
5
27.6
35 13
Tommy-knocker Imperial
9-Nov-07
11
27.6
40 21
Victory All Malt Lager
22-Dec-00
7
27.4
34 16
Flying Dog Garde Dog
12-Jul-08
15
27.4
35 18
Rogue Chipolte Ale
6-Jul-07
11
27.36
41 17
Hacker-Pschorr Weisse
2-Jun-07
9
27.22
38 10
Troegs Troegenator
7-Apr-07
9
27.18
41 18
Troegs Sunshine Pils
12-Jul-08
16
27.13
37 10
Anderson Valley Poleeko Gold
23-Feb-01
6
27
32 20
Melbourn Bros Cherry
6-Jul-07
11
26.91
37 17
Sierra Nevada Summerfest
12-Jul-08
16
26.73
34 23
Lagerhead Lager
7-Apr-07
9
26.56
42 20
Blue Star Wheat
2-Jun-07
9
26.56
42 17
River Horse Hop Hazzard Pale Ale
23-Feb-01
6
26.5
38 20
Shiner 97 Bohemian Black Lager
7-Apr-07
9
26.22
39 20
John Barleycorn
21-Jul-07
5
26.2
33 22
Michelob Pale Ale
12-Feb-00
5
26
30 21
Widmer Hop Jack Pale Ale
23-Feb-01
6
26
36 19
Bells Winter White Ale
8-Feb-08
12
26.08
36 11
Samuel Smith Pure Lager
7-Apr-07
9
25.89
40 15
Brooklyn East India IPA
21-Jan-01
5
25.8
35 22
Lakefront Big Easy
7-Apr-07
9
25.44
35 8
JW Lees Moonraker (7.5% abv)
13-Feb-07
8
25
31 8
Fuller's IPA
21-Jan-01
5
25
33 18
Acme IPA
21-Jan-01
5
25
34 15
Harpoon UFO
2-Jun-07
9
24.89
35 13
New Glarus Spotted Cow
12-Jul-08
12
24.75
35 10
Oliver's Ironman Pale Ale
12-Feb-00
5
24.4
36 14
1809
2-Jun-07
9
24
32 13
Miller Genuine Draft
22-Dec-00
7
23.8
34 18
Pyramid Hefeweisen
2-Jun-07
9
23.11
39 12
Dogfish Head Shelter Pale Ale
3-Mar-00
5
23
29 13
Bass Pale Ale
12-Feb-00
5
23
30 14
Otter Creek Vermont Lager
7-Apr-07
9
22.89
37 11
Schrimshaw Pilsner
7-Apr-07
9
22.78
39 11
Wolavers Pale Ale
12-Feb-00
5
22.6
28 12
Wild Goose IPA
21-Jan-01
5
20.8
24 17
Water Gap Wheat
2-Jun-07
9
20.44
40 7
Red Dog (Miller)
22-Dec-00
7
20.14
28 13
Spanish Peaks Yellowstone Ale
3-Mar-00
5
19.8
27 6
Schmidts
22-Dec-00
7
19.4
38 12
Clipper City Lager
22-Dec-00
7
17.2
29 7
Yards Extra Pale Ale
23-Feb-01
6
14.83
23 8
Double Diamond Ale
12-Feb-00
5
14.8
23 5
Caledonian Golden Pale Ale
23-Feb-01
6
12
28 4

 

Back to WBAS Archives